UPS vs NPS vs OPS: Which Pension Scheme is Best for Government Employees?

Rate this post

The new Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) was approved on 24th August 2024 and is set to be implemented from 1st April 2025. This development has captured the attention of government employees across the country, who are eager to understand the features and benefits of this scheme compared to the existing Old Pension Scheme (OPS) and National Pension System (NPS).




Detailed Explanation with Calculations for the Features of the New UPS Scheme

Assured Pension:

Feature: The scheme provides an assured pension of 50% of the average basic pay drawn over the last 12 months before superannuation, for a minimum qualifying service of 25 years.

  • Example : Employee A has an average basic pay of ₹60,000 over the last 12 months and has completed 25 years of service.
    • Assured Pension = 50% of ₹60,000 = ₹30,000 per month.

The pension amount is proportionately reduced for service periods between 10 and 25 years.

  • Example: Employee B has an average basic pay of ₹60,000 over the last 12 months but has only completed 15 years of service.
    • Service Ratio = 15 years / 25 years = 0.6 (60%)
    • Assured Pension = 50% of ₹60,000 × 0.6 = ₹18,000 per month.

Average:

Completed Years of ServicePension Amount (% of Last 12 Months Average Salary)
2550%
2448%
2346%
2244%
2142%
2040%
1938%
1836%
1734%
1632%
1530%
1428%
1326%
1224%
1122%
1020%

This table reflects how the pension amount is proportionate to the number of years of service completed, based on the last 12 months’ average salary.

Assured Family Pension:

Feature: The scheme ensures that the employee’s family receives 60% of the pension that the employee was receiving immediately before their demise.

  • Example : Employee A was receiving a pension of ₹30,000 per month before passing away.
    • Assured Family Pension = 60% of ₹30,000 = ₹18,000 per month.

Assured Minimum Pension:

Feature: The scheme guarantees a minimum pension of ₹10,000 per month upon superannuation, provided the employee has completed at least 10 years of service.

  • Example : Employee C has completed 12 years of service, with an average basic pay of ₹15,000 per month.
    • Even though 50% of ₹15,000 is ₹7,500, the employee will receive the assured minimum pension of ₹10,000 per month, as it is higher.

Inflation Indexation:

Feature: Pensions, including assured pension, family pension, and minimum pension, are indexed to inflation using the All India Consumer Price Index for Industrial Workers (AICPI-IW).

Dearness Relief:

Feature: Pensioners receive Dearness Relief (DR) based on the AICPI-IW, similar to serving employee

Lump Sum Payment at Superannuation:

Feature: Upon superannuation, employees receive a lump sum payment in addition to gratuity. This payment is calculated as 1/10th of the monthly emoluments (pay + DA) for every completed six months of service.

in addition to assured pension and gratuity.

  • Example: Employee A has a monthly emolument of ₹70,000 (including pay + DA) at the time of superannuation and has completed 30 years (or 60 (30*2) for every six-month periods of service) of service.
    • Lump Sum Payment = (1/10th of ₹70,000) × 60 = ₹7,000 × 60 = ₹4,20,000.
    • Employee A receives ₹4,20,000 in addition to their assured pension and gratuity.

Shifting option from NPS to UPS:

If Still in Service: No time limit shift anytime before retirement

If Already Retired: They can switch and will get arrear with Interest

Comparison table outlining the key differences between the Unified Pension Scheme (UPS), National Pension System (NPS), and Old Pension Scheme (OPS):

FeatureUnified Pension Scheme (UPS)National Pension System (NPS)Old Pension Scheme (OPS)
IntroductionTo be implemented from 1/4/2025 Introduced in 1/1/2004
(For All citizens including NRI aged between 18-70 years)
Existed before NPS (till 31/12/2003), phased out for new employees
Pension Basis50% of the average basic pay of the last 12 monthsMarket-linked, depends on the performance of selected fundsFixed pension based on the last drawn salary
Employee Contribution10% of salary10% of salaryNo employee contribution
Government Contribution18.5% of salary14% of salaryFully funded by the government
Assured PensionYes, 50% of last 12 months’ average basic payNo assured pension, dependent on market returnsYes, fixed pension amount based on last drawn salary
Investment OptionsBalanced approach with some assuranceMultiple investment optionsNo investment options, defined benefit scheme
Family PensionYes, 60% of the employee’s pensionNo specific family pension componentYes, family pension available
Tax BenefitsYes, offers tax benefitsSubstantial tax benefits under Sections 80C and 80CCDLimited tax benefits, pension received is taxable
Risk FactorRisk-free with guaranteed returnsMarket risks based on fund performanceRisk-free, guaranteed returns
Lump Sum Benefit1/10th of monthly emoluments for every six months of service60% – Lump sum
40% Annuity
No lump sum, only defined pension
Inflation IndexationYes, inflation-linked increments post-retirementNo specific indexation, depends on fund returnsYes, with inflation-linked increments

In conclusion, understanding the nuances of UPS, NPS, and OPS is crucial for making an informed decision about retirement planning. Each scheme offers unique benefits tailored to different needs and risk appetites. While OPS provides guaranteed financial security without market risks, NPS offers flexibility with potential for higher returns, albeit with associated risks. The newly introduced UPS aims to bridge the gap between the two by offering assured returns with some flexibility, making it an attractive option for those seeking a balance between security and growth. As retirement planning is a critical aspect of financial security, evaluating these options carefully will help government employees choose the scheme that best aligns with their long-term goals and expectations.


Visit www.cagurujiclasses.com for practical courses




Pooja Gupta

CA Pooja Gupta (CA, ISA, M.com) having 15 years of experience. Educator and Digital Creator

Disclaimer:- The opinions presented are exclusively those of the author and CA Guruji Classes. The material in this piece is intended purely for informational purposes and for individual, non-commercial consumption. It does not constitute expert guidance or an endorsement by any organization. The author, the organization, and its associates are not liable for any form of loss or harm resulting from the information in this article, nor for any decisions made based on it. Furthermore, no segment of this article or newsletter should be employed for any intention unless granted in written form, and we maintain the legal right to address any unauthorized utilization of our article or newsletter.

CA Pooja Gupta (CA, ISA, M.com) having 15 years of experience. Educator and Digital Creator

Leave a Comment